"Time is Life"

Home » Post Item » An Open Letter of Michael O. Mastura: MOA-AD

An Open Letter of Michael O. Mastura: MOA-AD

August 27, 2008

Dear All,

We don’t have money to further enrich the national dailies with a whole page AD.  So I do have to settle for alternative media prints “a la pobre”.  But it has the benefit of global interconnectedness.  Here’s my initial salvo to Frank’s ADS on MOA-AD.  I will elaborate my commentary much later.  For the sake of a broader debate, please help circulate this Open Letter on the MOA-AD.

Yours truly, Datu Michael O. Mastura

 

An Open Letter
24 August 2008

My reply email was interrupted by a brownout amidst my composing thoughts I wanted to convey to our readers at the Mindanews website besides Luwaran website.  Hopefully someone from the editorial box of the national dailies (in particular PDI) will pick as news items warranting some space the legal views of lawyers (like me) who represent MILF as the real Party in interest across the GRP-MILF negotiating table.

The series of full page ADS in PDI 08/22/08 and PD 08/23/08 of former senate president Frank M. Drilon simplify and focus on perceived infringements to the 1987 Constitution.  Those two Q & A pages make up powerful arguments for the continuing extension of what I call the “colonisibility status” of the Bangsamoro people, posing the matter of immediate infringement as a danger.

If we think rationally out of the maddening reactive anti-Moro sentiments generated by opinion-editorials and hardly balanced media coverage of the Government-MILF peace process, it makes me reflect the ‘triumph of diplomacy’ in our era of postmodern states. [N. B. this phrase is taken from the title of a book on how the Moro rulers of the Magindanaw sultanate and the Sulu sultanate had survived the era of treaty-making with Spain, an imperial power, and Holland, a commercial power, of the time and the United States up to 1916, when President Woodrow Wilson enunciated seminal ideas of the right to self determination.] Thus, there is no occasion to speak of Balkanization of this ungovernable part of the region.

Now the Country (el Pais)—Las Islas Filipinas—has just awakened to the depth of the Bangsamoro legitimate GRIEVANCES.  Instead of killing the ideas—the CAUSE (or SABAB)—embodied in the MOA-AD, the representatives of Government must face up to the Agreed Text as STATECRAFT.  It vindicates the JUSTNESS of the ORIGINAL POSITIONS to fix in constitutional construct. Traditional Moro negri (statehood) ‘earned sovereignty’ is encapsulated by the Republic in its present form and structure as an autonomous entity presently in existence before the family of nations since 1946.

Spokespersons for that Sovereign state called the Republic of the Philippines (GRP) configure their constituencies into a political community.  Such an assumption neglects a number of contested constitutional issues before the negotiating table.

What is the “territorial integrity” of the Philippines? When reduced to geographic maps with proper technical coordinates, the fundamental question we formally raised at the GRP-MILF Talks are as follows:

1. Is the present national territorial delimitation based on the Treaty of Paris of 10 December 1898 as corrected by the Treaty of Washington of 7 November 1900 and the treaty between the United States and England on 2 January 1930? Or,
2. Is it the current technical description of the archipelagic doctrine based on R.A. 3046 of 1961, as amended by R.A 5446 of 1968 as a system of straight baselines, its negotiating position on boundary delimitations under the United Nations Law of the Sea Convention?

An act of statesmanship is to ‘write sovereignty’ in terms of the ‘associative ties’ envisaged in the MOA-AD.  We cannot proceed with a serious debate as if the meaning of sovereignty were stable; for, in reality, not one but various forms of sovereign statehood exist. There’s no confusing justice with legitimacy for workable arrangements here.  However, there’s a truncated understanding of sovereignty when 12 June 1898 was fixed by law as an episodic event, following the inauguration of Philippine independence on 4 July 1946. Article 1 of Title I of the Malolos Constitution succinctly reads: “The political association of all the Filipinos constitutes a nation, whose state is called the Philippine Republic”.  At that point in time, the Bangsamoro homeland was not a part of the whole Country, for as a matter of historical narrative that Republic invited the Sultan of Sulu and the Sultan of Magindanaw to federate with it.

What matters for us present generation of patriots is that Driion’s half-a-million-worth of PDI ADS highlights the absolute necessity for a change in the first principles of the unitary system. How do we, then, fit inter-subjective understandings of ‘statehood’?  Former senate president Drilon, at least, seriously confronts the arenas of debate over the MOA-AD, but why does he not concede to explore the course of constitutionalism beyond the status quo of the existing constitutional order? That is unfortunate, because, what is placed before the Supreme Court is a new “elegant formula” of negotiability to balance between state sovereign authority and the right to self determination.

We need to examine the MOA-AD on the foundation of the formal division of sovereignty that favors “state rights” that have inhered in the Bangsamoro people, whose ancestral homeland was “illegally and immorally annexed” to the Republic without their plebiscitary consent.  Peace negotiations are said to be “the war after the war”.  Here, too, there is a subtle but in-depth way of looking at what amount of central authority in point of fact is compatible with “what is worth dying for” in the eyes of the majority of Bangsamoros in the contemporary politics of identity.

This is what the MILF-GRP negotiation process is all about: to determine the extent and limits of each side’s commitments. Clearly the premise of peace with your Muslim brothers under the MOA-AD precisely does not endanger but entrench the Country’s sovereignty.  The MOA-AD achieves, rather than contemplates the use of naked coercive force, the desirable levers of division, allocation and distribution of powers; in other words, shared and residuary authorities for the Bangsamoro people and the rest of the Filipino people.  All I can advance for now as an explanatory note is that the “general welfare clause” of the Philippine Constitution matching the principle of maslaha wal mursalah in Islamic constitutionalism is a catch all framework to accommodate “a medley of associative ties and tiers”.

I will elaborate on these points in a separate commentary on specific provisions of the MOA on AD. If only a healthy environment for serious debate is not drowned out by the intrusion of the mass media into the negotiating process that now encourage the politics of fear at the Metro Manila capital while excessive use of force are applied to villages in Mindanao, we can peaceably settle the conflict in Mindanao.

All the best,
Datu Michael O. Mastura

Source:  http://blog.wyzemoro.com/

 

 

Posted by kakaalih at 5:12 am | permalink

Previous Comments

Tandaan mo, at itago mo ito sa iyong puso

Posted by links of london at October 1, 2010, 5:36 pm

Transformer un grand ridicule, on en ridicule devient également.

Posted by coach factory outlet at December 6, 2010, 11:50 am

How wonderful! Break a leg!

Posted by Coach Outlet at December 20, 2010, 9:57 am

Ancestral Domain (MOA-AD) sa Kuala Lumpur Malaysia ay di natuloy noong Agosto 5,

Posted by Juicy Couture Outlet Online at May 24, 2011, 3:02 pm

Furthermore, they can get everything they really want from the Canada goose coats. So it is absolutely wise to make a perfect choice from canada goose collections. [Ling]

Posted by canada goose at June 21, 2011, 3:32 pm

ond MLB Women Jerseys, the organization has identified the joint of my people the fact of treason , he has now fled the . He knew the relationship between the two of us could start your investigation from what I have and the chip , you still have to pay attention to their own safety Minnesota Twins Jerseys, after all, this person , but my teachers. But do not

Posted by Arizona Diamondbacks Jerseys at June 24, 2011, 8:31 am

so many new style replica oakley sunglasses online up to 65% off. they enjoy oakley sunglasses discount at wholesale price, and cheap oakleys and oakley sunglasses sale now.

Posted by replica oakleys at June 27, 2011, 5:00 pm

top quality cheap ray bans on the cheap ray ban sunglasses mall, there are new styles ray bans on sale, just to do ray ban sunglasses sale there.

Posted by ray ban sale at June 27, 2011, 5:07 pm

Lian Wan , the suspect put a hot water bottle. This morning had finished with the Baogu boxing, but also helped Baogu the lunch ready. Yang Xi should not have a small appetite has increased

Posted by Oakley Sunglasses Cheap at June 29, 2011, 2:44 pm

Hey! friends, I have found a online shop that includes a lot of beautiful Air Jordan 2010, I have bought some jewelry from the Women Puma Store,the quality of the products is good i am pleased with these nike dunks i think u are pleased with these Men’s Puma Future Cat too, u can also have a try here is the shop: coach outlet store! These Nike Dunk SB are in addition to the existing Coach Outlet Store, which are center favorites. We have an Prada Handbags leasing team that works with hundreds of Prada Shoes either already in the outlet sector or looking to open an Air Jordan Shoes. Leasing is an art not a science and our leasing Nike air Jordan Shoes has a great track record in merchandising our centers across the country and the world. Some Prada Sneakers also post open positions on their corporate websites.In addition to supporting the openings planned for Coach Outlet Online, they are still focused on leasing the remainder of phase Puma Shoes, as well as phase nike dunk shoes, which is planned for a late Coach Handbags opening.

Posted by coach purses at July 29, 2011, 7:11 pm

Should the BJE be denied the right to cooperate with the national government to protect and promote regional and national interests?

Posted by oakley frogskins at August 2, 2011, 11:20 am

You have to believe in yourself. That’s the secret of success.
http://www.asicstigermall.net/

Posted by Asics Tiger at August 15, 2011, 4:50 pm

Pursue your object, be it what it will, steadily and indefatigably.
http://www.cheapjordancollection.com/

Posted by Cheap Jordans at August 15, 2011, 5:00 pm

With the excellent the actual running shoe michael jackson jordan shoes,michael jordan shoes,michael jordan sneakers,Air Jordan 1
,jordan retro 1,air jordan 1 shoes,jordan 1 shoes,Jordan 1,jordan retro 1 shoes,air jordan 2 shoesselling, 1 the game of basketball athletic shoe was in a position to customise the facial skin on the small business that is comparable to the oxygen Nike jordans boots and shoes air jordan 2,jordan 2 shoes,jordan 2,jordan retro 2,jordan retro 2 shoes,air jordan 3 shoes
,air jordan 3,jordan 3 shoes
,jordan retro 3,jordan retro 3 shoes
,jordan 3,own. Word on your transfer is the fact during respect into the Erika Jordan/Air The air jordan shoes air jordan 4 shoes
,air jordan 4,jordan 4 shoes
,jordan 4,jordan retro 4 shoes
,jordan retro 4,air jordan 5 shoes
,air jordan 5,jordan 5 shoes
,jordan 5,jordan retro 5 shoes
,jordan retro 5,endowment, we can simply provide Twenty-three models in the Air Jordan shoes air jordan 6 shoes
,air jordan 6,jordan 6 shoes
,jordan 6,jordan retro 6 shoes
,jordan retro 6,air jordan 7 shoes
,air jordan 7,jordan 7 shoes
,jordan 7,jordan retro 7 shoes
,jordan retro 7,to repay unique popularity along with enjoyment to assist you to Robert himself. And as Nike last of all produced the particular 23rd performance of services, it’s Air Jordan Fusion 5
,Jordan Fusion 5,jordan 2009
,air jordan 2009,jordan 2009 shoes
,air jordan 2009 shoes,air jordan 2010
,air jordan 2010 shoes,jordan 2010
,jordan 2010 shoes,air jordan 2011
,air jordan 2011 shoes,jordan 2011 shoes
,jordan 2011,undoubtedly estimated going without shoes can be just as faddish and also well known because it is Nike air jordan air jordan 8 shoes
,air jordan 8,jordan 8 shoes
,jordan 8,jordan retro 8 shoes
,jordan retro 8,air jordan 9 shoes
,air jordan 9,jordan 9 shoes
,jordan 9,jordan retro 9 shoes
,jordan retro 9,descendants. Up to date inclusion do not sadden equally it is makers and also buyers by means of just how much on the market pleaser it gotten. The actual shoe’s air jordan 10 shoes
,air jordan 10,jordan 10 shoes
,jordan 10,jordan retro 10 shoes
,jordan retro 10,air jordan 11 shoes
,air jordan 11,jordan 11 shoes
,jordan 11,jordan retro 11 shoes
,jordan retro 11,shade option ended being a put in homage to help you Mike’s clients undertaking, past time Air Jordan 6 Lakers, and also fire Air Jordan Motorsports. This approach gentle develop ultimately hyperlink to Mike’s possibly widely known shirt selection 3 self-confident the placed in the actual The nike jordan air jordan 12 shoes
,air jordan 12,jordan 12 shoes
,jordan 12,jordan retro 12 shoes
,jordan retro 12,air jordan 13 shoes
,air jordan 13,jordan 13 shoes
,jordan 13,jordan retro 13 shoes
,jordan retro 13,air jordan 14 shoes
,air jordan 14,jordan 14 shoes
,jordan 14,footwear make. When for starters notion the particular trainer offers jordan retro 14 shoes
,jordan retro 14,air jordan 15 shoes
,air jordan 15,jordan 15 shoes
,jordan 15,jordan retro 15 shoes
,jordan retro 15,air jordan 16 shoes
,air jordan 16,jordan 16 shoes
,jordan 16,jordan retro 16 shoes
,jordan retro 16,what could be thought about an expert motorsport start looking. Typically air jordan 17 shoes
,air jordan 17,jordan 17 shoes
,jordan 17,jordan retro 17 shoes
,jordan retro 17,air jordan 18 shoes
,air jordan 18,jordan 18 shoes
,jordan 18,jordan retro 18 shoes
,jordan retro 18,air jordan 19 shoes
,air jordan 19,the images on this certain Jordan footwear jordan 19 shoes
,jordan 19,jordan retro 19 shoes
,jordan retro 19,air jordan 20 shoes
,air jordan 20,jordan 20 shoes
,jordan 20,jordan retro 20 shoes
,jordan retro 20,air jordan 21 shoes
,air jordan 21,jordan 21 shoes
,jordan 21,jordan retro 21 shoes
,jordan retro 21,were unable just interesting at first, however air jordan 22 shoes
,air jordan 22,jordan 22 shoes
,jordan 22,jordan retro 22 shoes
,jordan retro 22,air jordan 23 shoes
,air jordan 23,a href=”http://www.somethingshop.com/air-jordan-23-cid991″>jordan 23 shoes
,jordan 23,jordan retro 23 shoes
,jordan retro 23,air jordan 24 shoes
,air jordan 24,they became within the far more hardcore Air Jordan jordan 24 shoes
,jordan 24,jordan retro 24 shoes
,jordan retro 24,air jordan 25 shoes
,air jordan 25,jordan 25 shoes
,jordan 25,jordan retro 25 shoes
,jordan retro 25,air jordan 26 shoes
,air jordan 26,jordan 26 shoes
,jordan 26,jordan retro 26 shoes
,jordan retro 26,Jordan 6 Rings shoes
,Air Jordan 6 Rings,running shoe jordan six rings
,cheap jordan six rings,Air Jordan Alpha Trunner
,jordan alpha trunner,air jordan classic
,jordan classic shoes,jordan flight 45
,air jordan flight 45,jordan flight 45 shoes
,Air Jordan Fusion 12,jordan fusion 12
,jordan fusion,Air Jordan Fusion 20
,Jordan Fusion 20,Air Jordan Fusion 3
,Jordan Fusion 3,fanatics very quickly whatsoever air jordan
,air jordan shoes,jordan shoes
,new jordan shoes,cheap jordan shoes
,sale jordan shoes,retro jordan shoes
,shop jordan shoes,jordan shoes for sale,jordan shoes for cheap
,jordan shoes on sale,wholesale jordan shoes
,cheap jordan shoe.

Posted by air jordan 10 at August 17, 2011, 12:05 pm

According to a consumer survey from Global fashion,the average person has six pair of Cheap True Religion Jeans,we can find that people are very favorite with jeans.In addition to feeling light and comfortable while wearing jeans,but even more slender and more attractive.Since the cheap True Religion Outlet are so popular,the designers of course will exhaust full efforts,coupled with the prevalence of different elements,like low-waist cut or embroidery style is this year’s best choice.See also attention to the part,and by using the i bandana patterns,we also poured specialty and originality True Religion Jeans Canada.From the good old days of vintage,True Religion crops has produced a sense of casual fun and unique personality.Creating things is not affected by the epidemic is a popular brand of candy can experience a sense of its own True Religion Canada.The anniversary season of 20 items has become a must see!Silhouette is finished in a beautiful little falls below the knee straight until tapered.Filled stitch design keeps sticking to the point True Religion Canada Outlet increased attention,as it is a new denim feel a sense of touch.Already have a reputation for discoloration as well as the new Cheap Supra Shoes.

Posted by True Religion Outlet at August 17, 2011, 4:28 pm

We offer discount price for you. When you order nike high dunk at our site .Every time I get the urge to finally give into a designer travel piece, I reconsider it and settle for nike dunk sb that I could use everyday instead.How about coming and having a look at our fine workmanship dunks shoes product.Come with cheap price and high quality.all types of nike dunks are designed to suit various body types; tall and full figured, tall and slim or even the right opposite.Every time I get the urge to finally give into a designer travel piece, I reconsider it and settle for nike dunks high that I could use everyday instead.Welcome to nike dunk onlineWithout any hesitation, this nike sb dunks will truly set your fashion styling for the spring and summer.Authentic nike dunk high is one of the best-selling merchandise.We also offer other newest and best shoes.This cheap nike sb dunk high eliminated my foot pain and I have Frieberg’s disease and bought these as my last resort before surgery.And we now offer free shipping for every order until 1st when you want to get nike dunk low.Buy nike dunk hi from online store which supported 24/7 service.??nike sb dunk?? is very popular. Recently my friend and I always play them.We offer discount price for you. When you order nike dunk hi at our site .dunk sb is Personalityit represent a symbol of fashion,taste.And dunk high shoes can give you these feeling which you want to find.What a miracle and I now bought sb dunks,too!sb dunks on sale.nike dunk low are on hot sale in UK,can’t you miss this chance?Unlike the other nike dunk low shoes, this nike dunk low features bright romantic color which is quite suitable for the summer time.What a miracle and I now bought dunk nike,too!dunk nike on sale.You also are struggling to find a good cheap nike high dunks? We provide high quality nike high dunks. 83af4030-dfa4-11e0-a248-867967aa798e

Posted by nike high dunk at September 16, 2011, 9:58 am

Buy nike dunk low online now at Shop!Discounted 25% off.Free Shipping!However,a beautiful part of tnike sb dunk go more black heels. Heel is the perfect size, as a certain proportion of stacked heel.nike high dunks are an important part of our life.nike dunk hi Shoes is the essential material needs in our life,it is the social civilization development product.nike dunk low discount with good quality and beautiful patterns.thank you for selecting dunk high hope you like.sb dunks have different designs.nike dunk is the best seller in our online store.Promod sell their own branded quality dunk sb, most of which are in the style of some more expensive designer labels.Our dunks shoes are a perfect combination of classics and fashion.You can choose your favorite style.nike dunk low is indeed the world’s best shoes.Great discount of dunk nike are sold nearly at its cost and free shopping.the newest and best nike dunks are cheap in our shop.These nike dunk hi are sold hot on supra footwear store,especially the nike dunk hi shoes is the best selling shoes.the women plays an important part of the world nike high dunk.You don’t even have to walk out of the indoor circumstance, and your slim,beautiful and grace leg could easily catch people’s eyes.When you pull on a pair of nike sb dunks.Do you love sports, do you feel like to look cool, i got a very awesome website here introduced by one of my friends.such as nike dunk high.Here you can find all kinds of latest styles of nike dunks high,including nike dunks high Shoes and so on.nike sb dunk high keep you motivated.It was a very nice idea! Just man say thank you for the information you have shared nike dunk sb. 8c71f97e-dfa4-11e0-a248-867967aa798e

Posted by nike dunk low at September 16, 2011, 10:34 am

I had buy many shoes from hyperdunk low website, this web cheap price and good quality.nike hyperdunk low have different designs.the hyperdunk 2011 Shoes is a popular clothing item in Hip Hop Culture and among gabber music fans.nike dunk in the design and development, the use of more efficient models to reduce waste.If you are original discount nike hyperdunk 2011 in the back, you are of the timesToday I found a kind of nike hyperdunks which the first time I saw, I fall in love with it.It is very simple that the nike dunks of getting healthy starts by promoting a positive view of life.Our website offer a service of 6 different ways nike hyperdunk for your payment. 3bddb6d2-e1df-11e0-af7e-8ec972781a0a

Posted by hyperdunk low at September 20, 2011, 9:16 am

Moncler Jackets  Moncler Down Coats  Moncler Vests   Moncler Sale    Moncler Down Jackets     Moncler Polo Shirts    Moncler Shoes

Posted by Moncler Kids Jackets at October 6, 2011, 2:50 pm

Cheap Christian Louboutin Discount Louboutin Shoes。Christian Louboutin Sale,Louboutin Sale
Louboutin Pumps  Christian Louboutin Boots  Christian Louboutin Sandals  Christian Louboutin Platforms  Christian Louboutin Slingbacks  Christian Louboutin Booties  Christian Louboutin Sneakers  Christian Louboutin Flats

Posted by Christian Louboutin at October 6, 2011, 2:51 pm

oh my!! i love you so much!!

Thank you so much.

I support you.

http://www.louisvuitton4lover.com/

Posted by Louis Vuitton online at October 27, 2011, 1:31 pm

This young man went out there and I have not heard a word from him. I don’t know what became of him, and I don’t know whether Adidas Predator Cleats found any mines or not, but I don’t believe he ever did. As I come here to-night and look around this audience I am seeing again what Nike Mercurial Victory Red White through these fifty years I have continually seen – men that are making precisely that same mistake. I don’t believe he ever discovered Indoor Soccer Shoes, and if I am looking in the face of any stockholder of that copper company. lonny.http://www.soccer4shoes.com/

Posted by Adidas F50i Tunit Start Kit at February 13, 2012, 11:17 am

http://www.beatsbydrebeatsheadphoness.org.uk

Posted by dre beats at March 19, 2012, 10:27 am

coach outlet
http://www.coachoutletonlinekk.com
coach outlet online
http://www.coachoutletnn.com
louis vuitton
http://www.louisvuittonukday.org.uk
louis vuitton outlet
http://www.louisvuittonoutletuks.org.uk

Posted by louis vuitton at March 19, 2012, 10:35 am

dre beats http://www.beatsbydrebeatsheadphoness.org.uk
beats headphones http://www.drdrebeatsbyheadphones.org.uk
polo ralph lauren uk http://www.poloralphlaurenuks.org.uk
coach outlet online
http://www.coachoutletonliney.com

Posted by dre beats at March 19, 2012, 10:36 am

Come to Coach Factory Outlet and find brand new Coach Factory Shoes Ivory Gray here, which are one of the casual, leisure yet uncommon Coach Factory shoes for women on sale. He is the oldest of the group and takes it upon himself to motivate his fellow Survivors. Coach Factory Online facial features are portrayed by Darnell Rice and he is voiced by Chad Coleman. coach factory outlet online is one of the four playable survivors in Left 4 Dead 2. He was a high school health teacher and coordinator for the freshman football team before the Infection hit his hometown of Savannah.

Posted by coach factory outlet at April 11, 2012, 2:48 pm

Thank you for your work , I am very interested in your story , you are very concerned about our readers , and articles written by very close to our lives

Posted by Cheap Jerseys at May 18, 2012, 12:42 pm

Add a comment